WILL BUSH APPROVE A MODIFIED HATE BILL?
By Rev. Ted Pike
7 May 07
In a moment of high political drama last Thursday, the President
informed the House of Representatives that if Congress passed the
hate crimes bill they were gathered to debate, his top advisors recommended
he veto it. His warning reassured frightened lovers of freedom that,
regardless of the actions of headstrong Democrats, our Commander
in Chief could bring the hate bill to nothing.
Bush powerfully explained his opposition to the hate bill. His
words showed that he’s well-informed about H. R. 1592’s
redundancy and dangers. His explanation is probably similar to what
he said as governor of Texas, when he vetoed the Anti-Defamation
League’s state hate law.
Despite the president’s reassuring promise, disturbing questions
remain. During his first term as president, Bush said he would approve “modified” hate
crime legislation. So we have to wonder whether he’ll approve
a “modified” federal hate law now.
What would a “modified” hate bill look like? By 2003
the hate bill suffered three defeats at the hands of Republicans.
So its advocates offered a compromise: they would “modify” the
hate bill. Up to that point, Sen. Orrin Hatch had steadfastly opposed
the Hate Crimes Prevention Act. Yet he accepted the Democrats’ compromise
and soon made a stunning announcement: he now supported the hate
bill! He said it had been “modified” to ease his primary
fear, that no checks and balances were available against rampant
hate crime indictments from the federal government. The “modified” bill
required that the federal government take no action without approval
from the U.S. attorney general and his or her subordinates; Hatch,
satisfied with compromise, joined with Sen. Edward Kennedy in promoting
hate bill passage in the Senate.
But if a president as corrupt as Bill Clinton appoints an attorney
general of the same character, like Janet Reno, then Hatch’s
supposed check on federal power is useful as a Kleenex in a flood.
Instead, Hatch blathered that America “should grow up and pass
the hate bill.”
In the months following 2004 passage of the Kennedy-Hatch hate
crimes amendment in the Senate, Hatch sobered and returned to opposition
of the federal hate crimes legislation. He must have realized he
had been carried away by a superficial “modification” without
freedom-saving substance. In fact, the new ADL hate bill was even
worse than the original! It allowed the federal government to intervene
in hate crime trials whenever it didn’t approve of the verdict.
It also granted federal jurisdiction for any felony or violent crime
in the nation, not just hate crimes!
What do we learn from the snookering of Hatch? It could happen
again. ADL, desperate to finally pass their dream legislation, could
well offer Bush the “modified” version he once said he
But however ADL and the Democrats might prune a modified bill,
it will still contain their poisonous essentials. First, it will
include the terms of the original 1969 federal hate bill. This empowers
the government to prosecute anyone who attempts to verbally “intimidate” a
homosexual away from enjoyment of privileges or professions (including
as a clergyman, Scout leader or P.E. coach) he desires. Second, it
will include establishment of a bias-motivated justice system in
America, where bias motivating a crime (such as refusal to rent an
apartment to a homosexual or hire him as a youth director in your
church) becomes justification for federal prosecution in the states.
Lastly, even a modified bill will unify federal and state jurisdiction
in law enforcement. This is the definition of a police state.
Time to Relax?
After the president’s warning of a veto, visits to our website
fell by half. Clearly, many concerned Americans think they can relax
now that the president has promised to intervene. They think the
hate bill crisis is over.
I disagree. I suspect the only reason Bush intervened now is because
the number of alarmed hate bill opponents is so high that we are
viewed as a significant political bloc, worthy of placation. The
hate bill has gone before Congress four times during the Bush presidency,
being approved alternately by the Senate and House. I don’t
remember Bush similarly coming forward when the number of protesters
was lower. He certainly was non-committal two months ago.
If the nation begins to relax about the hate bill threat, the president
probably will, too, and become open to compromise. There can be no
compromise with H.R. 1592 or S1105. This legislation is toxic, designed
by ADL for one reason: to take away our freedom.
Rather than putting our future into the hands of a politician,
lovers of freedom must continue to fight this battle ourselves. We
must solidly defeat the hate bill in the Senate. The Senate Judiciary
is overwhelmingly pro-hate bill and we can expect the bill to move
rapidly within the next several weeks. Yet our chances of victory
in the Senate are much greater than in the House. We only need to
persuade about 7 senators to vote “nay” in order to deprive
ADL of the necessary 60 votes to pass.
At www.truthtellers.org we list the 14 Republicans who voted for
the hate bill in 2004 and also the 17 Republicans who are currently
not declaring their stand. We must inundate these crucial Republican
Senators with calls this week, especially informing the members of
the Senate from our district that if he or she votes for the hate
bill, we and our friends will never vote for them again. It’s
especially important that you send your senator and his influential
8-10 aides my powerful flyer, “Anti-Hate Laws Will Make You
a Criminal.” (Flyer
and aides are available here.)
Call Republicans first. But don’t neglect to call Democrats.
If you are a constituent send them and their aides my flyer. In the
2005 vote in the House only 5 Democrats voted against the hate bill.
But in last week’s House vote, 14 Democrats crossed the aisle
to vote with the Republicans against H.R. 1592! It may well be that
the intellectual ferment of the many thousands of my flyers sent
into Congress in the last several months has worked on the minds
and consciences of these Democrat legislators, opening previously
closed minds. The same could happen in the Senate.
This is the week, before the hate bill comes to a vote in the Senate,
for one more upheaval of truth and protest. Victory against the hate
bill in the Senate is vastly preferable to presidential veto. It
would re-establish the credibility and prestige of the American people
as those who control our destiny. Second, it would complete an enormous
education program campaign in Congress, prejudicing many in the Senate
against hate crime laws for years to come.
Push Forward to Victory
Only several months ago in mid-February, the new right and its
leaders were virtually oblivious to the hate bill’s existence
before the House. Since then, concern among Christian and conservative
leaders has exploded. Discussion of the bill is also overflowing
to the secular print media where articulate Republicans are raising,
for the first time, incisive objections to hate laws. If this groundswell
continues, it could pressure President Bush to veto all freedom-stealing
legislation now being ramrodded through Congress by the Democrats.
This is not a time to pull back and relax. It’s time to aggressively
reassert our control of government. We must support all members of
Congress who oppose hate laws and let Bush know America tolerates
The battle for freedom is now, not tomorrow. Let’s overwhelm
senators of both parties with calls, faxes, emails, and my hate laws
flyer. Call toll free 1-877-851-3467.
Don’t neglect to call the White House as well at 202-456-1111.
Leave this message: “Thank you, Mr. President, for promising
to veto the hate bill. I expect you to also reject any modified hate
Rev. Ted Pike is director of the National Prayer Network, a Christian/conservative
watch dog organization.
Let the Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith teach you how they
have saddled 45 states with hate laws capable of persecuting Christians:
Learn how ADL took away free speech in Canada and wants to steal
it now in the U.S. Congress. Watch Rev. Ted Pike's Hate
Laws: Making Criminals of Christians at video.google.com. Purchase
this gripping documentary to show at church. Order online at www.truthtellers.org for $24.90, DVD or VHS, by calling 503-853-3688, or at the address
TALK SHOW HOSTS: Interview Rev. Ted Pike on
the threat of hate laws, both federal and state. Call (503) 631-3808.
National Prayer Network, P.O. Box 828, Clackamas,